top of page


At the Cotgreave Agency we take pride in assisting you in obtaining the very best insurance product at a fair price. Here is how we can assist you...


We pride ourselves in doing the right job for our clients. Our sales professionals will complete a full evaluation and analysis on your current insurance policies. We ensure you are covered accurately so there are no surprises. Insurance should be there when you need it the most. We identify inconsistencies and always look for savings.


Cotgreave Insurance Agency has been serving Long Island residents for over 30 years. With our successful history, we have had the fortune to align ourselves with prestigious carriers. Based on your personal or business needs, we determine the right fit for you. With ample companies to choose from, we ensure you are with the best carrier and the best premium.

We know you work hard to be successful and want to safeguard your business and your personal finances. After our analysis and determination of carrier, Cotgreave will handle the rest. We shop, you save. Our staff of professionals are always here to answer your questions.


To obtain a Quote, or, to discuss your existing Risk Management & Loss Mitigation strategies for your Business Insurance, as well as your existing insurance policy coverage(s), at no cost or obligation to you, please click below:


Important Notice
Any submissions or payments made via this website do not constitute a binding agreement to your policy or coverages. Changes and payments to policies are not effective or binding until you, or any party involved, receive official notice from either your insurance agent, or your insurance company. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact us.

Per the terms of our online privacy policy we will not resell your information to any third-party.


  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn Social Icon
  • Instagram


Monday - Friday 

8:30 am to 5:00 pm


Saturday & Sunday



Evenings by Appointment


558 Portion Road 

Ronkonkoma, NY 11779


Tel: (631) 981-5400

Fax: (631) 981-5448

bottom of page